KTVL CBS Channel 10 Mailing List

News10 LiveLinks from BroadcastDrive Safe Mode
KTVL CBS Channel 10 :: News - Top Stories - Fire Service stands by Biscuit decisions

Friday, July 13 2012, 10:40 AM CDT
Fire Service stands by Biscuit decisions
By Hillary Brown/KTVL.com

SELMA, Ore.― The summer of 2002 presented the perfect storm of circumstances for the blaze that would become known as the Biscuit Fire. 

That summer, flames scorched nearly 500,000 acres, burned four homes and left an indelible mark on communities throughout the Illinois Valley.

Illinois Valley Fire District Captain Tom Zulliger worked the Biscuit Fire.  Looking at the scorched hills of the Kalmiopsis Wilderness, he can remember the lightning strikes that sparked the fires, as well as the actions that sparked controversy.

“I don’t know what they were thinking.  I know what they did,” Zulliger said as he spoke about the U.S. Forest Service’s response to the flames. “They didn’t take action on it for awhile.”

At the time it burned, the Biscuit Fire was Oregon’s largest and most expensive wildfire in recent history.  Controlling the flames took nearly two months and efforts to extinguish it completely lasted through the remainder of 2002.

Five fires combined to create the Biscuit Complex.  The first of the five was sparked when a line of dry lightning storms moved through Northern California and Southern Oregon beginning July 12, 2002.  There were 12,000 strikes over the course of three days, according to the U.S. Forest Service.  The strikes started 375 small fires.  The lightning added fuel to growing concerns that had already been fanned by increasing temperatures and a lack of resources.

“Two thousand two was another huge fire season in the southwest and Rocky Mountain area, so a lot of our local resources had been deployed to those areas,” said Paul Galloway of the U.S. Forest Service. “This is remote country.  The burning conditions were at the extreme level.”

Following the Biscuit Fire, Oregon representatives Greg Walden, Peter DeFazio and Scott McInnis requested a review of the reaction to the natural disaster.  The U.S. General Accounting Office did an investigation into the fire response, resource availability and personnel certification standards.  The goal of the report was to determine whether fire management had reacted appropriately to the fire and whether the mass burn could have been prevented.

The first two fires that would become part of the Biscuit were the Carter Fire and Biscuit 1. Crews were able to contain the Carter fire, according to the Forest Service.  By the time crews were able to get to the Biscuit 1, daylight was running out and access was an issue. 

Fire managers decided to let it burn.

The next day -- July 13 -- three more fires were identified.  All of those fires were in rugged areas and weren’t threatening homes.  Again, the decision was made to let them burn and to use the limited resources available on other fires.

It’s a move Illinois Valley Fire District Captain Joe Feldhaus understood.

“It was in the middle of an area that hadn’t burned in quite awhile, out in the wilderness,” he said. “Then, once it got its steam, there were other fires that needed attention, so it did not get the resources that it would have initially.”

The GAO report revealed the first 24 hours of a fire attack are crucial to getting flames under control.  Ninety-nine percent of fires aggressively fought in that time frame are extinguished.  Galloway agreed with that analysis, but said there was more at play with the Biscuit fires.

“The other fires were less accessible.  By the time we got there, with the resources that we had, they wouldn’t have been successful.  So we need to assess that, as far as safety for our firefighters and staff, are we putting them in a situation where, one, they can’t be successful and, two, they’re dealing with some pretty extreme fire behavior with limited safety zones and escape routes. Why would you do that?”

CALLS FOR HELP

Many people questioned the Forest Service's decisions as the fires burned larger and began to join together.  When the fires first started, the Forest Service called regional managers looking for support. 

News10 interviews and the government’s assessment of the response revealed differing answers as to whether fire managers called California for aide. 

The GAO said California was not called because fire managers assumed the state was busy fighting its own fires.

Galloway said California was contacted, but its offer of help was turned down for several reasons, including the limited time the helicopter would be available.

“We had that offer,” Galloway said. “Given the size of the fires, the availability of the helicopters was very limited as far as the time they'd be able to spend on the fire. The assessment was made that given the help that they were offering, it wasn’t going to be significant enough to try and engage them.”

Galloway went on to say that the overall lack of resources put the whole Forest Service in a tough position.

 “We had waivers that we could use mechanized equipment within the wilderness, drop retardant within the wilderness, those kinds of things were in place during the fire,” he pointed out.  “It’s just that, in order to utilize that stuff, you have to have boots on the ground and we couldn’t get them there.”

By July 17, the fires had been declared one for administrative purposes.  The combined fires were called the Biscuit Complex.  Within 10 days, the Forest Service was calling the fire “explosive.” Josephine County activated its Emergency Operations Center and evacuation notices were issued for the entire Illinois Valley.

“It was coming.  It looked like it was coming,” Feldhaus said. “It looked like it was going to come into the valley.” 

As fire managers made another controversial decision to back burn into the fire to protect towns, community members were growing more unhappy with the strategy and were concerned the back burns were too large.

“Honestly, people were mad at the Forest Service,” Feldhaus said. “They were mad that the Forest Service had let it go.”

The Forest Service maintained that’s what it had to do to protect people and homes.  On August 3, 2002, a fire behavior computer model gave a 70 percent probability that one segment of the fire would burn over communities in the Illinois Valley within 48 hours.

“Firefighters put in over 40 miles of fire line to try to halt the fire and minimize the impact,” Galloway said. “Pretty heroic stuff.”

LOOKING BACK

The Biscuit Fire was declared contained 55 days after it began and was controlled 119 days after the first starts. 

In all, the fire burned 499,570 acres and cost nearly $155 million to fight.  Four residences had been burned and 10 other structures lost.

As the tenth anniversary of the fire neared, the Forest Service continued to defend its actions.  A representative pointed out that no firefighters had been killed while battling the flames and no towns had been burned.

Looking back, Galloway said the decisions that were made were ones that put people and homes above everything else. Despite the questions and controversies, the Forest Service is standing by its decisions and its crews and crediting them for keeping the Biscuit Fire from becoming a larger disaster than it already was.

“There’s still a lot of emotion that’s tied to the event, whether you’re the resident and still want to do the armchair quarterbacking.. or the agency person,” Galloway said.  “It was a tough year.  We did what we could do with what we had. I don’t think many of the decisions, if any of the decisions, that were made during the first few days of that fire event would change much today.”

ONLINE

General Accounting Office Report on the Biscuit Complex Fire

Biscuit Fire from Space

Interactive Biscuit Fire Maps

READ MORE
From Awesome Glow to Scorched Earth: Remembering the Biscuit



Fire Service stands by Biscuit decisions

[an error occurred while processing this directive]

Related Stories

  • KTVL :: Community - Mr. Food

    Mr. Food

    See the most recent TV Recipes & Videos!
  • KTVL :: Community - Auto Preview

    Auto Preview

    Catch the 2015 Auto Preview show here!
  • KTVL :: Community - Providence Healthy Avenues

    Providence Healthy Avenues

    Providence gives you the inside scoop on how to make your life healthier and easier one week and one minute at a time.
  • KTVL :: Community - Ray's Stuff The Truck

    Ray's Stuff The Truck

    Join us in the fight against hunger!
  • KTVL :: Community - LIVE with News10 <br> Good Morning

    LIVE with News10
    Good Morning

    Every morning the News10 Good Morning takes you LIVE to the events affecting YOUR community. Miss the morning broadcast? News10 has you covered -- all of the videos are available here.
  • KTVL :: Community - Health and Beauty

    Health and Beauty



  • KTVL :: Community - Automotive

    Automotive

    Find valuable information about buying your next car, including price quotes and your latest automotive news.
  • KTVL :: Community - Community Toy Drive

    Community Toy Drive

    Find out how you can help today!
  • KTVL :: Community - Community Calendar

    Community Calendar

    Looking for something to do? Check the events calendar.
  • KTVL :: Community - Gas Prices

    Gas Prices

    Gas prices are on everybody's mind. So News10 is working with Gas Buddy to help you find the cheapest gas in the area.
  • KTVL :: Community - West Coast Flavors

    West Coast Flavors

    Who doesn't love good food? News 10 invites area chefs to the West Coast Appliance kitchen to cook up their favorite recipes.




KTVL Top Stories

Klamath County Sheriff sues Board of Commissioners, Peace Officers

Controversy over Normal Neighborhood plan continues

Thirty Italian students spend two weeks in sister city

Gold Hill Couple Sentenced for Child Abuse

La Clinica Wellness Center Opens

Man and officer wounded, dog killed in police address mix-up

USOC endorses Los Angeles for 2024 Olympics bid

Senate leader: Not enough votes to defund Planned Parenthood

Man who got life for marijuana charge goes free in Missouri

Haggen sues Albertsons for $1 billion over grocery deal

McDonald's will launch all day breakfast on Oct. 6

Federal judge orders Kentucky clerk and her staff to court

Google refines logo as it prepares to join Alphabet

FDA issues warning letters to powdered caffeine distributors

Missing person in Phoenix

Pacific Crest Trail now open through Crater Lake park

Blues, brews, and barbeque

Local social media group asks for your help

Slow season for some golf courses

Prevent human caused wildfires

OMSI tent at Josephine County Fair

Fossils show big bug ruled the seas 460 million years ago

Two car crash in Williams

Fan's death at Braves game raises stadium safety questions

Kids Unlimited Academy Expands Extracurriculars

Landscaping Strips Gardens at Talent Senior Community

Suspect in Houston-area deputy's death had mental evaluation

Lost California hiker survived 9 days with broken leg

Arrest in Medford Armed Robbery

Judge sides with anti-abortion group in birth control case

18-year-old charged in shooting death of Eugene teen

In-home child care providers face unannounced inspections

Grant Pass Fire Rescue improves ISO rating

Horror movie director Wes Craven dies at 76

Kanye for 2020? White House welcomes rapper's political bid

Alaska-bound, Obama renames America's tallest peak

Police: Woman said boys weren't loved, so she drowned them

Oregon firefighters helped by lighter winds, cooler temps

Community Emergency Response Team creates 72-hour kits

Structure Fire Forces Couple to Evacuate

Car wash for toys

Federal Money for Firefighters

Homelessness on the Rise

Radar detects object believed to be missing Nazi gold train

US oil prices climb again after Thursday's big jump

Jacksonville tattoo shop grand opening

George W. Bush visits disaster zone, 10 years after Katrina

Teacher who was late 111 times says he was eating breakfast

TV shooting survivor's husband recounts story before gunfire

Former prep school student convicted of sex charges

Union requests faster resolution to Klamath County Sheriff investigation

State may approve up to $15-hour wages for home-care workers

Firefighters at Oregon wildfire prepare for windy weather

Kapowsin Meats recalls pork from Washington, Oregon, Alaska

Oregon hiring 11 recreational marijuana inspectors

Texas PTA's one-of-a-kind fundraising sheet strikes a familiar chord with parents

Daycare accused of drugging infants with Benadryl

Holly theatre restoration project

Habitat for humanity's biggest project underway

Klamath Falls Police & OSP Ready If Needed

Sex abuse education in schools

Klamath County Budget Breakdown

Plane diverted due to smoke

Planned Parenthood alleges 'smear' in letter to Congress

Californians cut water without state imposing fines

Children's Advocacy Center Highlights Abuse in Jackson County

Gold Hill Couple Found Guilty of Child Abuse

Ruling could ease way for unionizing at fast-food chains

Twitter tries to lure in users as it searches for CEO

Girls named Destiny questioned in cliffside vandalism case

'Sister Wives' cite gay marriage ruling in polygamy case

Rogue River Police arrest domestic assault, arson suspect

Audit: Oregon Lottery can't detect illegal casinos

Puffin abandoned by parents get second chance

Owners of hiking cat say it may be 'part-dog'

McCloud man's death determined to be natural

Couple found guilty in child abuse case

Starkist Offering $25 Refund or $50 of Tuna as Part of Settlement

Police investigate Medford stabbing

Mayor thanks US student who helped thwart France attack

Humbled Vick at peace in reserve role with Steelers

Investigation: EPA, state missed potential for mine blowout

Your Sports: 08.26.2015

Asphalt Spill Into Ashland Creek

Medford school district pushes for better grad rates

State Department officials routinely sent secrets over email

Custom Crushing Business Grows

Wine Harvest Starts Early

DEVELOPING: Klamath deputies requested leave due to alleged retaliation, harassment

Mormons keep affiliation with Boy Scouts despite gay leaders

None injured in Central Point house fire

Klamath County Sheriff Office speaks on investigation

Oregon soldiers ready to fight wildfire near John Day

Oregonians will get $402 million in 'kicker' rebates

Reporter, cameraman killed on air; gunman dies

Fire in Gold hill destroys home

Middle school moving to Cascade Christian High School campus

Education to fit every student

Department of Justice Investigates Klamath Co. Sheriff's Office

Kingsley Field's Airmen Fighting Fire Across The State

Fire crews eye weather as heat, wind build in parts of West

Utah boy survived night in woods by curling up in warm rocks

Just Mayo maker warned by FDA that mayonnaise needs eggs

Mascot fight between school, Ohio goes down to the wire

Weed Growers Approve of Industrial Hemp Permit Hiatus

Temporary Housing Introduces New Sprinkler System for Medford Fire-Rescue

Medford police plan second pedestrian operation for August

Red Cross provides free smoke alarms to Medford residents

Official: Oregon hemp industry not what was envisioned

Police arrest son of State Commissioner of Labor in connection with fatal stabbing

Horses with 'extremely severe' hoof neglect rescued from Washington Co

Restaurant Uses Large Sign to ‘Get Back’ at Wells Fargo Bank

Former meat worker accused of stealing sausage

Man arrested after trying to trade meth for firearm

Attorney general probes Klamath County Sheriff's Office

Rollover crash in Grants Pass leaves two teens injured

Poverty in Klamath Falls

Klamath Falls Police Increase Foot Patrol

100 Pounds of Meth Disguised as Food Items for Children Seized in Baldwin County

Driverless truck meant to improve safety in work zones

No tolerance policy for teachers

Chromebooks stolen from new charter school

Historic Elks lodge in Medford up for sale

Judge dismisses suit claiming bourbon was falsely advertised

High-Tech Skills Needed

Pints or Pipeline?

Klamath County Sheriff's Deputies placed on leave

Syracuse Police: Mom threatens children with knife, fiance records it as joke for Facebook

Teen arrested on trespass, firearm possession in West Medford

2 men held without bail for alleged threats to Pokemon event

Record wildfire in Washington gets international, local help

State says Portland's mobile medical marijuana cart illegal

Teens are shopping more like their parents

Police: Louisiana trooper dies after being shot in head

Sanctuary One seeks adoption for neglected animals

How to prepare during peak fire season

The Second Century: Josephine County Fair

Car Wash Fundraiser for Families in Car Crash

Klamath County Gets More Medical Examiners

Hike the Pipe

Local Fires Crews Are Back Home

Car Wash For Children

Non-Perishable Food Needed

Ratrod-O-Rama... A Success!

Detectives work on unusual Jeep thefts

Developers struggle to keep up with seniors

Living Among The Branches

First "Poverty Simulation" for Southern Oregon

Bridging Together Employers and Potential Employees

[an error occurred while processing this directive]
Should your town impose a 1-year moratorium on medical marijuana dispensaries?
ASHLAND, Ore. (AP) — One of Oregon's more liberal cities is considering a moratorium on medical marijuana dispensaries.

The Ashland Daily Tidings newspaper reports that the Oregon Health Authority Medical Marijuana Dispensary Program has already received six dispensary applications for Ashland.

But neighborhood opposition has been increasing and the council will discuss a moratorium on April 1.

People hoping to launch dispensaries in Oregon began submitting applications to the state on March 3 as part of a new medical marijuana regulatory system.

A proposed dispensary called Top Shelf Meds abuts an Ashland neighborhood.

Carol Kim says the dispensary is separated from her home by a hedge. She says it's ironic that state rules bar dispensaries near schools, but her daughters will come home from school and have to live near a dispensary.
___

Copyright 2014 The Associated Press.
YES
My town should definitely impose the moratorium for one year -- no more, no less.
NO
My town should NOT impose the moratorium for any length of time. My town should follow current state laws on medical marijuana dispensaries.
Undecided
I am unsure whether I am in favor of medical marijuana dispensaries in my town, regardless of current state laws.

Business News

Major business and economic events scheduled for Wednesday

WASHINGTON (AP) -- Several major economic reports are due out today. The Labor Department will release second-quarter productivity data and the Commerce Department will release factory orders for July this morning. The Federal Reserve will release its Beige Book early in the afternoon.

Consumer Info

   WEST PALM BEACH, FL -- (Marketwired) -- 03/21/14 --
 Companies that pride themselves on being eco-friendly may have conflicted
 ideas between marketing with ad specialties and maintaining their green
 reputation. ...

Entertainment News

IDRIS ELBA: BOND WRITER DISMISSES HIM AS "TOO STREET" FOR 007 ROLE

LONDON (AP) -- The man who wrote the new James Bond novel thinks people might be reading between the lines too much about his comments on casting for the movie based on the book.

Get This

OFFICER IMPERSONATION-REAL OFFICER

MANASSAS, Va. (AP) --The fake cop tried to stop a real police officer.

Science/Tech News

IN THE NEWS: UBER SUIT GETS CLASS-ACTION STATUS

SAN FRANCISCO (AP) -- More legal headaches for Uber.


 
  • KTVL :: News - City In Crisis

    City In Crisis



  • KTVL :: News - Drive Safe Mode

    Drive Safe Mode

    Help keep you and your loved ones safe on the road, Pledge against distracted driving and support safety on our roads.
  • KTVL :: News - News10 Special Report

    News10 Special Report

    News10 investigates the issues affecting your town.
  • KTVL :: News - News10 Feed

    News10 Feed

    Headlines in YOUR town.
  • KTVL :: News - Across The Nation

    Across The Nation

    News and information from across the nation.
  • KTVL :: News - Border Crisis

    Border Crisis



  • KTVL :: News - Elections Day

    Elections Day

    Elections are in full swing in your town.Stick with News10 as the ballots continue to be submitted!
  • KTVL :: News - The Great Outdoors

    The Great Outdoors

    Join KTVL News10 for The Great Outdoors, a weekly segment featuring numerous activities related to outdoor living in Southern Oregon and Northern California.
  • KTVL :: News - Health Matters

    Health Matters

    Local Health Care Professionals Providing You With Helpful Health Tips!
  • KTVL :: News - Your Voice. Your Future.

    Your Voice. Your Future.

    As the country faces challenges from federal budget issues to jobs and national debt, your voice is critical to the future.
  • KTVL :: News - Health Care Reform

    Health Care Reform

     The Supreme Court ruling to uphold the Affordable Care Act sparked a new battle. Check here daily for the latest developments, locally and across the country.
  • KTVL :: News - Tasty Topics

    Tasty Topics

    We've all seen News10's Trish Glose tasting food on West Coast Flavors. Now she has more space to talk about food and drink!
  • KTVL :: News - Washington Times

    Washington Times

    Politics, Breaking News, US and World News.
  • KTVL :: News - Reality Check

    Reality Check

    How are your tax dollars being spent? Reality Check tracks whether local, state and federal governments or any groups are using your money wisely...or wasting it.
  • KTVL :: News - Your View

    Your View

    When you see news, share it with us. Your View is the perfect place to share the video and photos you capture your town.
  • KTVL :: News - Closings & Delays

    Closings & Delays

    Check here for closures and delays.
  • KTVL :: News - On The Town

    On The Town

    On the Town highlights local entertainment activities from concerts at the Craterian, to plays, parades and fun runs, for the week and weekends in Medford and counties in Southern Oregon.
  • KTVL :: News - To Your Health

    To Your Health

    Dr. Dan, Monday KTVL News10 at 5 answers your health questions and discusses the latest developments in medecine. If you have questions, find the e-mail address and mailing address at ktvl.com.
  • KTVL :: News - Crime Stoppers

    Crime Stoppers

    Crime Stoppers, Medford, Southern Oregon's answer to crime at ktvl.com. Find a police report of the active case, descriptons of suspects, vehicle information, rewards.

  • KTVL :: News - Rogue Gangs

    Rogue Gangs

    Gangs are a growing concern for police in Southern Oregon and Northern California. News 10 is taking an in-depth look at the issue.
  • KTVL :: News - Links from Our Broadcast

    Links from Our Broadcast

    Links and numbers from our newscasts at KTVL News10, Medford, Southern Oregon's news source. Relevant links to research topics of interest or to contact organizations.

  • KTVL :: News - Consumer Links

    Consumer Links

    Consumer information, links and numbers. Useful links to protect and educate the consumer from the Oregon and California State Departments, the federal government and other Associations.
  • KTVL :: News - Safety Links

    Safety Links

    Safety - links and numbers at ktvl.com. Emergency preparedness plans for Curry, Jackson, and Josephine counties' citizens. Links to California and Oregon Emergency Management Offices, National Safety Council, ...
  • KTVL :: News - Voting Links

    Voting Links

    Links to websites full of information and background material, as well as sites that help you take action.
  • KTVL :: News - Local Links

    Local Links

    Local links for Medford, Southern Oregon and Northern California. Community links for Curry, Josephine, Jackson, Klamath, Lake and Siskiyou Counties, schools, cities, chambers of commerce, Rogue Valley ...

more »

Tonight on KTVL

12:00pm:  News10 at Noon
12:30pm:  The Bold and the Beautiful
  1:00pm:  The Talk
  2:00pm:  Let's Make A Deal
  3:00pm:  Rachael Ray
  4:00pm:  Ellen
  5:00pm:  News10 at 5pm
  5:30pm:  CBS Evening News with Scott Pelley
  6:00pm:  News10 at 6pm
  6:35pm:  Who Wants to be a Millionaire
  7:05pm:  Family Feud
  7:30pm:  Celebrity Name Game
  8:00pm:  The Briefcase
  9:00pm:  Criminal Minds
10:00pm:  CSI: Cyber
11:00pm:  News10 at 11pm
11:35pm:  The Late Show, with David Letterman
12:37am:  The Late Late Show

Complete Schedule »