KTVL CBS Channel 10 Mailing List

News10 LiveLinks from BroadcastDrive Safe Mode
KTVL CBS Channel 10 :: News - Top Stories - Experts questions 'Jesus Wife' papyrus

Wednesday, September 19 2012, 05:40 PM CDT
Experts questions 'Jesus Wife' papyrus
By Nicole Winfield/Associated Press

ROME (AP) -- Is a scrap of papyrus suggesting that Jesus had a wife authentic?

Scholars on Wednesday questioned the much-publicized discovery by a Harvard scholar that a 4th century fragment of papyrus provided the first evidence that some early Christians believed Jesus was married.

And experts in the illicit antiquities trade also wondered about the motive of the fragment's anonymous owner, noting that the document's value has likely increased amid the publicity of the still-unproven find.

Karen King, a professor of early Christianity at Harvard Divinity School, announced the finding Tuesday at an international congress on Coptic studies in Rome. The text, written in Coptic and probably translated from a 2nd century Greek text, contains a dialogue in which Jesus refers to "my wife," whom he identifies as Mary.

King's paper, and the front-page attention it received in some U.S. newspapers that got advance word about it, was a hot topic of conversation Wednesday at the conference.

Christian tradition has long held that Jesus was unmarried, although there is no reliable historical evidence to support that, King said. Any evidence pointing to whether Jesus was married or had a female disciple could have ripple effects in current debates over the role of women in the church.

Stephen Emmel, a professor of Coptology at the University of Muenster who was on the international advisory panel that reviewed the 2006 discovery of the Gospel of Judas, said the text accurately quotes Jesus as saying "my wife." But he questioned whether the document was authentic.

"There's something about this fragment in its appearance and also in the grammar of the Coptic that strikes me as being not completely convincing somehow," he said in an interview on the sidelines of the conference.

Another participant at the congress, Alin Suciu, a papyrologist at the University of Hamburg, was more blunt.

"I would say it's a forgery. The script doesn't look authentic" when compared to other samples of Coptic papyrus script dated to the 4th century, he said.

King acknowledged Wednesday that questions remain about the fragment, and she welcomed the feedback from her colleagues. She said she planned to subject the document to ink tests to determine if the chemical components match those used in antiquity.

"We still have some work to do, testing the ink and so on and so forth, but what is exciting about this fragment is that it's the first case we have of Christians claiming that Jesus had a wife," she said.

She stressed that the text, assuming it's authentic, doesn't provide any historical evidence that Jesus was actually married, only that some two centuries after he died, some early Christians believed he had a wife.

Wolf-Peter Funk, a noted Coptic linguist, said there was no way to evaluate the significance of the fragment because it has no context. It's a partial text and tiny, measuring 4 centimeters by 8 centimeters (1.5 inches by 3 inches), about the size of a small cellphone.

"There are thousands of scraps of papyrus where you find crazy things," said Funk, co-director of a project editing the Nag Hammadi Coptic library at Laval University in Quebec. "It can be anything."

He, too, doubted the authenticity, saying the form of the fragment was "suspicious."

Ancient papyrus fragments have been frequently cut up by unscrupulous antiquities dealers seeking to make more money.

An anonymous collector brought King the fragment in December 2011, seeking her help in translating and understanding it. In March, she brought it to two papyrologists who determined it was very likely authentic.

On Tuesday, Harvard Divinity School announced the finding to great fanfare and said King's paper would be published in January's Harvard Theological Review. Harvard said the fragment most likely came from Egypt, and that its earliest documentation is from the early 1980s indicating that a now-deceased professor in Germany thought it evidence of a possible marriage of Jesus.

Some archaeologists were quick to question Harvard's ethics, noting that the fragment has no known provenance, or history of where it's been, and that its current owner may have a financial interest in the publicity being generated about it.

King has said the owner wants to sell his collection to Harvard.

"There are all sorts of really dodgy things about this," said David Gill, professor of archaeological heritage at University Campus Suffolk and author of the Looting Matters blog, which closely follows the illicit trade in antiquities. "This looks to me as if any sensible, responsible academic would keep their distance from it."

He cited the ongoing debate in academia over publishing articles about possibly dubiously obtained antiquities, thus potentially fueling the illicit market.

The Archaeological Institute of America, for example, won't publish articles in its journal announcing the discovery of antiquities without a proven provenance that were acquired after a UNESCO convention fighting the illicit trade went into effect in 1973.

Similarly, many American museums have adopted policies to no longer acquire antiquities without a provenance, after being slapped with successful efforts by countries like Italy to reclaim looted treasures.

Archaeologists also complain that the looting of antiquities removes them from their historical context, depriving scholars of a wealth of information.

However, AnneMarie Luijendijk, the Princeton University expert whom King consulted to authenticate the papyrus, said the fragment fit all the rules and criteria established by the International Association of Papyrologists. She noted that papyrus fragments frequently don't have a provenance, simply because so many were removed from Egypt before such issues were of concern.

She acknowledged the dilemma about buying such antiquities but said refraining from publishing articles about them is another matter.

"You wouldn't let an important new text go to waste," she said.

Hany Sadak, the director general of the Coptic Museum in Cairo, said the fragment's existence was unknown to Egypt's antiquities authorities until news articles this week.

"I personally think, as a researcher, that the paper is not authentic because it was, if it had been in Egypt before, we would have known of it and we would have heard of it before it left Egypt," he said.

Maggie Fick in Cairo contributed.
Experts questions 'Jesus Wife' papyrus

[an error occurred while processing this directive]

Related Stories

  • KTVL :: Community - Mr. Food

    Mr. Food

    See the most recent TV Recipes & Videos!
  • KTVL :: Community - Auto Preview

    Auto Preview

    Catch the 2015 Auto Preview show here!
  • KTVL :: Community - Providence Healthy Avenues

    Providence Healthy Avenues

    Providence gives you the inside scoop on how to make your life healthier and easier one week and one minute at a time.
  • KTVL :: Community - Ray's Stuff The Truck

    Ray's Stuff The Truck

    Join us in the fight against hunger!
  • KTVL :: Community - LIVE with News10 <br> Good Morning

    LIVE with News10
    Good Morning

    Every morning the News10 Good Morning takes you LIVE to the events affecting YOUR community. Miss the morning broadcast? News10 has you covered -- all of the videos are available here.
  • KTVL :: Community - Health and Beauty

    Health and Beauty



  • KTVL :: Community - Automotive

    Automotive

    Find valuable information about buying your next car, including price quotes and your latest automotive news.
  • KTVL :: Community - Community Toy Drive

    Community Toy Drive

    Find out how you can help today!
  • KTVL :: Community - Community Calendar

    Community Calendar

    Looking for something to do? Check the events calendar.
  • KTVL :: Community - Gas Prices

    Gas Prices

    Gas prices are on everybody's mind. So News10 is working with Gas Buddy to help you find the cheapest gas in the area.
  • KTVL :: Community - West Coast Flavors

    West Coast Flavors

    Who doesn't love good food? News 10 invites area chefs to the West Coast Appliance kitchen to cook up their favorite recipes.




KTVL Top Stories

Two Jackson County Medical Marijuana Businesses duke it out

AllCare Health breaks ground

Public input wanted for transportation plan

Crash on Interstate 5

Airline will fly between Klamath Falls and Portland

GOP House chairman calls on Obama to remove IRS commissioner

Nike offers partial refund to end FuelBand lawsuit

Walker says EPA should be limited 'umbrella organization'

House backs bill to help vets who've suffered sexual assault

Jackson County Sheriff's Office evacuated due to suspicious package

Boy Scout board approves end to blanket ban on gay adults

Man possibly linked to missing women had contact with police

Bush denounces 'crazy message of hate' in campaign

Mother pleads for return of missing California 8-year-old

Scientist: Whale deaths off Alaska island remains mystery

Okla. woman attacked, killed by pack of dogs

Mom allegedly brings son along for Nashville burglaries

Massive search underway for teens who set out for Bahamas

Former 41-pound fat cat in Texas slims down to 19 pounds

Colorado governor supports Jordan Cove, Pacific Connector

Mental health experts respond carefully to mass killings

Police Impersonator

Portland Man Found

Final Day at Fair Brings Thousands

Pizza Served on West Main

Missing Portland man found

Fill the Boot for Jackson County Fire District 3

Heads Up Football Training Program Hits Eagle Point

Central Point Family Still Feeling Effects Of Storm From Two Weeks Ago

Dog Wash For A Good Cause

Mold Be Gone!

Grants Pass Apartment May Have Mold

Construction causes traffic delays at Crater Lake

Mercy Flights buys own helicopter

Bike Sharing: a new way of transportation

Can US housing industry's comeback endure? The outlook dims

Finding money for highways is becoming a bipartisan project

New inquiry into Clinton emails fuels political questions

Structure Fire on Spring Street sparks more

Mercy Flights Gets a New Chopper

Central Point couple charged with Elder Abuse

Bicyclist struck near Golden Wok in Medford

Fiat Chrysler recalls 1.4M vehicles to prevent hacking

Fire Danger level increase Tuesday for Jackson and Josephine Counties

Transportation Chief: 5 Airlines probed for price-gouging

Theater gunman's family called him mentally ill, violent

WWE cuts ties with Hulk Hogan amid report that he used slurs

National Hot Dog Day

The cost of going to the Jackson County Fair

Sanctuary Cities In Oregon?

GoFundMe Helps Medford Student Pay for College

Teacher Shortage in Medford

Neighbor hero in Medford Structure Fire

The Phoenix Plaza Project

Medford in the process of expansion

Campers flee Montana fire; California blaze threatens homes

Police: Man hid under bed for 3 days at ex-girlfriend's home

Prosecutor: Woman's autopsy revealed no evidence of homicide

DEVELOPING: Accidental Gunfire at Army Recruiting Center

House passes bill to prevent mandatory GMO labeling

Silent 911 call leads police to 5 dead in Oklahoma home

Memoir by mother of Columbine shooter coming in February

Small wildfire burns 2 cars in southern Oregon

Medical dispensary files lawsuit over Medford pot sale ban

Police detonate suspicious device in Grants Pass

Oregon allocates $62 million for affordable housing

Phoenix permits outdoor marijuana growth

D.A.'s office gets new building

USDA: Bird flu vaccine works on chickens; testing on turkeys

Your Sports: 07.22.2015

Federal G.M.O. Discussion

A Walk On The Wild Side At The Fair

Oink, Oink! Swine Auction's Tonight

Fake auto sale company claims to be in Medford

Report: Social Security disability fund to run dry next year

Police: Springfield man killed in self-defense, could be linked to other crimes

After 2 deaths, Ikea and government warn about dressers

Armed citizens guard recruiters after Tennessee shootings

Shell gets permits necessary for oil drilling in Arctic

Families seek justice for their loved ones in sanctuary cities

Children of ISIS: The next generation of terror?

Survival Documentary Fundraising in Ashland

Jackson County Fair ride inspections begin

Crime is Down in Medford

Living With Chronic Pain

Opioid Prescription Problem

Theater shooter may not be executed even if sentenced to die

Chipotle: Still no pork at 40 percent of restaurants

Becoming a dad? Expect to gain 3 to 5 pounds, study suggests

Group demands change in dam operations to protect frog

Feds say ID protector LifeLock violated $12M settlement

Ohio Gov. John Kasich announces run for the White House

Donald Trump gives out Lindsey Graham's personal cell number

18-year-old's video of gun-firing drone spurs investigation

Marijuana a no-go at Jackson County Fair

Bare-handed shark wrestler: 'I haven't got a scratch on me'

Man accused of killing 5 was to be charged with 2014 death

Citi to refund $700 million for deceptive card practices

Free Fire Alarms

Grants Pass considers sales tax for safety

Rogue River Murder Suspect Arraigned

Searching for ET: Hawking to look for extraterrestrial life

House to take up bill blocking money for 'sanctuary cities'

Police: Ex-NFL player's mistress kills his wife then self

Oregon resident worked as woman, collected disability as man

Detroit police seek men who robbed couples, raped the women

Cheating website Ashley Madison hacked, personal info posted

California proposes historic $1.5M fine for taking water

Families face tough decisions as cost of elder care soars

Siskiyou County Man Dies in Woodcutting Accident

No charges filed in May 19 fatal crash

Heavy rains collapse California bridge, bringing travel woes

Oregon finalizes its portion of West Coast Electric Highway

Blake Shelton, Miranda Lambert divorce after 4 years

New marijuana industry wrestles with pesticides and safety

McCain: Trump owes apology to veterans, not to him

Crowdfunding project aims to save Neil Armstrong's spacesuit

Suspect behind chemical device turns himself in

Atlas Race Participants Receiving Refunds

Beekman Bank Tour in Jacksonville

High-Speed Car Chase

Fishing Restrictions Now in Effect

Milking it for What it's Worth

Extreme Shortage Of Foster Families In Jackson County

Car Crashed Into Tree

Boy Scout Troop 112 Turns 100

County has close eye on fair food

Middleford alley brings downtown together

Carnival meets state safety requirements

Motorcycle stolen from Brammo Inc. in Talent

Utah police arrest 15-year-old boy in young girl's death

Hundreds of Medford residents not paying utility bill

Grants Pass police seek man wanted for ramming patrol car

Last Words From Slain Marine To Girlfriend: 'ACTIVE SHOOTER'

Hitchhiking robot embarks on coast-to-coast tour across US

How did gunman go from ordinary suburban kid to killer?

Bomb found at Klamath County Jail

Los Angeles burglar records video selfie with victim's phone

Apartment construction drives US homebuilding surge in June

RVTV Gets Extended Contract with Medford

18 and Driving an 18-Wheeler

Fire season better than expected

Medford City Council Talks Marijuana

Rental Prices On The Rise Across Jackson County

Traffic Fatalities on the rise in Oregon

Fish Deaths in Drought

Due to drought, Oregon curtails fishing for some species

TLC cancels '19 Kids and Counting,' plans education push

Jury finds Colorado theater shooter guilty of murder

California tells irrigation district to stop pumping water

Colorado theater shooting trial verdict reached

Officials: 4 Marines killed in military attacks in Tenn.

Texas probing death in jail of woman with Chicago ties

Applications for Oregon marijuana dispensaries growing

Dad found guilty of asking someone to beat up baby sitter

Siskiyou County Deputies cope with trauma

Your Sports: 07.15.2015

Nationwide G.M.O. Bans Under Threat

Car Dealerships Targeted

Access works to end homelessness in veterans

Uber fined $7M for keeping info from California regulators

Taxpayer service hits new low at IRS as 'Obamacare' kicks in

Fire Districts train for Wildland Fires

Farewell FAO Schwarz: Last day of business at NYC toy store

House speaker wants hearings on Planned Parenthood video

Shoppers disappointed in much-hyped 'Prime Day' sales

Grants Pass shooting leaves one dead

Infection, death rates for hepatitis C soar in Oregon

Police say woman, 35, used kids' identities to steal cars

Teenage vandals wreak havoc on Klamath County city

Josephine County libraries ask public for help

Sex Offense Charges Dropped

OReGO is a Go!

Regulating body cameras for officers

Officials: Connecticut is most expensive place to die in US

Obama calls for shorter sentences for nonviolent convicts

GM to keep sponsoring Kid Rock concerts, discuss flag issue

Seaweed that tastes like bacon hits Portland

US retail sales fall in June as consumers stay cautious

Health officials warn of arsenic levels in hand-dug clams

Father of missing baby in California dead

"Oregon Promise" grant to help pay community college tuition

Bird flu on rise

[an error occurred while processing this directive]
Should your town impose a 1-year moratorium on medical marijuana dispensaries?
ASHLAND, Ore. (AP) — One of Oregon's more liberal cities is considering a moratorium on medical marijuana dispensaries.

The Ashland Daily Tidings newspaper reports that the Oregon Health Authority Medical Marijuana Dispensary Program has already received six dispensary applications for Ashland.

But neighborhood opposition has been increasing and the council will discuss a moratorium on April 1.

People hoping to launch dispensaries in Oregon began submitting applications to the state on March 3 as part of a new medical marijuana regulatory system.

A proposed dispensary called Top Shelf Meds abuts an Ashland neighborhood.

Carol Kim says the dispensary is separated from her home by a hedge. She says it's ironic that state rules bar dispensaries near schools, but her daughters will come home from school and have to live near a dispensary.
___

Copyright 2014 The Associated Press.
YES
My town should definitely impose the moratorium for one year -- no more, no less.
NO
My town should NOT impose the moratorium for any length of time. My town should follow current state laws on medical marijuana dispensaries.
Undecided
I am unsure whether I am in favor of medical marijuana dispensaries in my town, regardless of current state laws.

Business News

Judge: BP payouts to local entities to start soon for spill

NEW ORLEANS (AP) -- A federal judge says BP will begin paying up to $1 billion in settlements to compensate local governments across the Gulf Coast for lost tax revenue and other economic damages they blame on the company's 2010 oil spill.

Consumer Info

   WEST PALM BEACH, FL -- (Marketwired) -- 03/21/14 --
 Companies that pride themselves on being eco-friendly may have conflicted
 ideas between marketing with ad specialties and maintaining their green
 reputation. ...

Entertainment News

BACHORLETTE' FINALE

LOS ANGELES (AP) -- "The Bachelorette" is sporting quite a rock on her ring finger.

Get This

LOBSTER DAY

PORTLAND, Maine (AP) -- Happy Lobster Day!

Science/Tech News

IN THE NEWS: NIKE OFFERS PARTIAL REFUND TO END FUELBAND LAWSUIT

NEW YORK (AP) -- Got a Nike FuelBand?


 
  • KTVL :: News - City In Crisis

    City In Crisis



  • KTVL :: News - Drive Safe Mode

    Drive Safe Mode

    Help keep you and your loved ones safe on the road, Pledge against distracted driving and support safety on our roads.
  • KTVL :: News - News10 Special Report

    News10 Special Report

    News10 investigates the issues affecting your town.
  • KTVL :: News - News10 Feed

    News10 Feed

    Headlines in YOUR town.
  • KTVL :: News - Across The Nation

    Across The Nation

    News and information from across the nation.
  • KTVL :: News - Border Crisis

    Border Crisis



  • KTVL :: News - Elections Day

    Elections Day

    Elections are in full swing in your town.Stick with News10 as the ballots continue to be submitted!
  • KTVL :: News - The Great Outdoors

    The Great Outdoors

    Join KTVL News10 for The Great Outdoors, a weekly segment featuring numerous activities related to outdoor living in Southern Oregon and Northern California.
  • KTVL :: News - Health Matters

    Health Matters

    Local Health Care Professionals Providing You With Helpful Health Tips!
  • KTVL :: News - Your Voice. Your Future.

    Your Voice. Your Future.

    As the country faces challenges from federal budget issues to jobs and national debt, your voice is critical to the future.
  • KTVL :: News - Health Care Reform

    Health Care Reform

     The Supreme Court ruling to uphold the Affordable Care Act sparked a new battle. Check here daily for the latest developments, locally and across the country.
  • KTVL :: News - Tasty Topics

    Tasty Topics

    We've all seen News10's Trish Glose tasting food on West Coast Flavors. Now she has more space to talk about food and drink!
  • KTVL :: News - Washington Times

    Washington Times

    Politics, Breaking News, US and World News.
  • KTVL :: News - Reality Check

    Reality Check

    How are your tax dollars being spent? Reality Check tracks whether local, state and federal governments or any groups are using your money wisely...or wasting it.
  • KTVL :: News - Your View

    Your View

    When you see news, share it with us. Your View is the perfect place to share the video and photos you capture your town.
  • KTVL :: News - Closings & Delays

    Closings & Delays

    Check here for closures and delays.
  • KTVL :: News - On The Town

    On The Town

    On the Town highlights local entertainment activities from concerts at the Craterian, to plays, parades and fun runs, for the week and weekends in Medford and counties in Southern Oregon.
  • KTVL :: News - To Your Health

    To Your Health

    Dr. Dan, Monday KTVL News10 at 5 answers your health questions and discusses the latest developments in medecine. If you have questions, find the e-mail address and mailing address at ktvl.com.
  • KTVL :: News - Crime Stoppers

    Crime Stoppers

    Crime Stoppers, Medford, Southern Oregon's answer to crime at ktvl.com. Find a police report of the active case, descriptons of suspects, vehicle information, rewards.

  • KTVL :: News - Rogue Gangs

    Rogue Gangs

    Gangs are a growing concern for police in Southern Oregon and Northern California. News 10 is taking an in-depth look at the issue.
  • KTVL :: News - Links from Our Broadcast

    Links from Our Broadcast

    Links and numbers from our newscasts at KTVL News10, Medford, Southern Oregon's news source. Relevant links to research topics of interest or to contact organizations.

  • KTVL :: News - Consumer Links

    Consumer Links

    Consumer information, links and numbers. Useful links to protect and educate the consumer from the Oregon and California State Departments, the federal government and other Associations.
  • KTVL :: News - Safety Links

    Safety Links

    Safety - links and numbers at ktvl.com. Emergency preparedness plans for Curry, Jackson, and Josephine counties' citizens. Links to California and Oregon Emergency Management Offices, National Safety Council, ...
  • KTVL :: News - Voting Links

    Voting Links

    Links to websites full of information and background material, as well as sites that help you take action.
  • KTVL :: News - Local Links

    Local Links

    Local links for Medford, Southern Oregon and Northern California. Community links for Curry, Josephine, Jackson, Klamath, Lake and Siskiyou Counties, schools, cities, chambers of commerce, Rogue Valley ...

more »

Tonight on KTVL

12:00pm:  News10 at Noon
12:30pm:  The Bold and the Beautiful
  1:00pm:  The Talk
  2:00pm:  Let's Make A Deal
  3:00pm:  Rachael Ray
  4:00pm:  Ellen
  5:00pm:  News10 at 5pm
  5:30pm:  CBS Evening News with Scott Pelley
  6:00pm:  News10 at 6pm
  6:35pm:  Who Wants to be a Millionaire
  7:05pm:  Family Feud
  7:30pm:  Celebrity Name Game
  8:00pm:  NCIS
  9:00pm:  NCIS: New Orleans
10:00pm:  48 Hours
11:00pm:  News10 at 11pm
11:35pm:  The Late Show, with David Letterman
12:37am:  The Late Late Show

Complete Schedule »