KTVL CBS Channel 10 Mailing List

News10 LiveLinks from BroadcastDrive Safe Mode
KTVL CBS Channel 10 :: News - Top Stories - Keeping the poker face: Judges learn to deal with emotions

Thursday, February 21 2013, 01:29 PM CST
Keeping the poker face: Judges learn to deal with emotions
By Mark Sherman/Associated Press

WASHINGTON (AP) -- A Florida judge's harsh reaction to a disrespectful teenage defendant, captured on court video, was a reminder that judges don't shed their emotions when they don their black robes.

The recent episode quickly went viral. But for a few dozen new federal judges, it became a lesson in finding ways to acknowledge they experience a range of feelings on the bench and to channel them appropriately.

"We tell judges, 'If you ever detect an emotion, squelch it.' That's an extremely bad idea," said Vanderbilt University law professor Terry Maroney, who led a session for roughly 40 judges in Washington that incorporated the Florida incident. "You're going to have emotions as a judge, no matter how many people tell you you won't or aren't supposed to."

In a Miami-Dade County courtroom, Circuit Judge Jorge Rodriguez-Chomat doubled an 18-year-old's bond when she laughed, then gave her 30 days in jail when she made an obscene gesture with her middle finger.

Several days later, she admitted she had been high on Xanax and alcohol and apologized to the judge. He erased the bond and let her go home.

U.S. District Judge Jeremy Fogel, who runs the Federal Judicial Center in Washington, said a judge's first year can be especially intense, and Maroney's aim is to help judges cope with the new stresses of the job, including the difficult task of sending another human being to prison.

"We don't do a lot to prepare them for that. Judges, when they're new, try particularly hard to live up to the expectations of the job. As you have more time and more experience, you realize you are not going to get it right every time. You have an obligation to try, but you can't, because we're all imperfect. It takes a while to come to terms with that," said Fogel, a veteran of 30 years as a judge in state and federal courts in California.

The discussion in Washington was held behind closed doors, but Fogel and two new judges agreed to talk about it and about their experiences on the bench.

U.S. District Judge John Gerard in Lincoln, Neb., served as a state Supreme Court justice for 16 years, hearing appeals generally argued in measured tones and in a sterile environment, at least compared to a courtroom trial. President Barack Obama nominated him to the federal judiciary in 2011, and he began his new job a year ago.

Among the most difficult situations Gerard has encountered involved white-collar fraud.

"Those are emotionally charged. You're trying to figure out what sentences to impose. You have the defendant's family members on one side. They sometimes have no idea of the details. On the other side are victims who have been defrauded or whose life savings are gone. Those are fraught situations," Gerard said. "I'm obviously going to base what I do on the law, but it's helpful to know it's OK when you do feel some anger, some revulsion."

U.S. District Judge John Fowlkes in Memphis, Tenn., had five years of trial experience as a state court judge before becoming a federal judge in August. Yet he still appreciated the chance to share his perspective with other recent Obama nominees.

Frustration, Fowlkes said, is what keeps popping up. Roughly 85 percent of the criminal defendants who come before him are young black males, and the details vary little, he said.

By and large, they lack education and skills, having dropped out of school at an early age. Often, they are part of a drug or gang culture, and they pass through the courtroom seemingly headed for life as a career criminal, he said.

"There is a wider societal problem that is continuously brought to me for some type of solution, and courts are not the place for it," Fowlkes said.

The first time Maroney did this sort of training session, last October in front more than 200 judges, she was surprised by how eager judges were to talk about emotions on the bench and share experiences from their somewhat isolated professional lives. "I worried that people would find it touchy-feely or some kind of therapy session, which it's not at all. I think it's important to give judges some breathing room," she said.

What she is trying to do is to adapt research on human emotion for use in the courtroom.

"The cultural message is that judges are supposed to be poker-faced. Well, not always," she said.

The Miami incident is useful to Maroney's work because it illustrates a debate over when "judicial anger can serve an important teaching function - showing that defendant the gravity of her situation, demanding appropriate respect for authority - and when it might instead reflect intemperance and, stated bluntly, a power trip," she said.

Another example Maroney is working into her presentation is the January sentencing of a serial killer by Justice Bonnie Wittner in New York State Supreme Court, the state's trial court.

"She cried while she was sentencing him. It was unusual enough that it got reported, but it got reported in a very non-judgmental way. It was extremely meaningful to the victims' families. It meant she cared. This is not a judge who is walled off and has lost all touch with humanity."

For Fowlkes, the moment that really got to him occurred during a murder trial in state court, before a jury rendered its verdict. The victim was a 4-year-old girl who was beaten to death. Her mother's boyfriend was on trial.

Prosecutors showed jurors the girl's picture. Her body was lying on a table in the medical examiner's office, just before the autopsy.

"It was as if she was just lying there asleep. You couldn't see any bruises. I don't know why that photo affected me the way it did," Fowlkes said.

He couldn't let his emotions show. "It's something I had to deal with inside," he said. "You just have to find a way of handling it so it does not adversely affect others."


Copyright 2013 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.Keeping the poker face: Judges learn to deal with emotions

[an error occurred while processing this directive]

Related Stories

  • KTVL :: Community - Mr. Food

    Mr. Food

    See the most recent TV Recipes & Videos!
  • KTVL :: Community - Ray's Stuff The Truck

    Ray's Stuff The Truck

    Join us in the fight against hunger!
  • KTVL :: Community - Health and Beauty

    Health and Beauty

  • KTVL :: Community - Automotive


    Find valuable information about buying your next car, including price quotes and your latest automotive news.
  • KTVL :: Community - Community Toy Drive

    Community Toy Drive

    Find out how you can help today!
  • KTVL :: Community - Community Calendar

    Community Calendar

    Looking for something to do? Check the events calendar.
  • KTVL :: Community - Gas Prices

    Gas Prices

    Gas prices are on everybody's mind. So News10 is working with Gas Buddy to help you find the cheapest gas in the area.
  • KTVL :: Community - West Coast Flavors

    West Coast Flavors

    Who doesn't love good food? News 10 invites area chefs to the West Coast Appliance kitchen to cook up their favorite recipes.

Should your town impose a 1-year moratorium on medical marijuana dispensaries?
ASHLAND, Ore. (AP) — One of Oregon's more liberal cities is considering a moratorium on medical marijuana dispensaries.

The Ashland Daily Tidings newspaper reports that the Oregon Health Authority Medical Marijuana Dispensary Program has already received six dispensary applications for Ashland.

But neighborhood opposition has been increasing and the council will discuss a moratorium on April 1.

People hoping to launch dispensaries in Oregon began submitting applications to the state on March 3 as part of a new medical marijuana regulatory system.

A proposed dispensary called Top Shelf Meds abuts an Ashland neighborhood.

Carol Kim says the dispensary is separated from her home by a hedge. She says it's ironic that state rules bar dispensaries near schools, but her daughters will come home from school and have to live near a dispensary.

Copyright 2014 The Associated Press.
My town should definitely impose the moratorium for one year -- no more, no less.
My town should NOT impose the moratorium for any length of time. My town should follow current state laws on medical marijuana dispensaries.
I am unsure whether I am in favor of medical marijuana dispensaries in my town, regardless of current state laws.

KTVL Top Stories

Golden Missions of America

Harry & David to hire for over 1,500 positions

Attorneys make closing cases in trial of Wisconsin gun shop

Evidence mounts for El Nino that could ease Calif. drought

California contest dubs 1,969-pound pumpkin the plumpest

Outcry in Connecticut brings back canceled Halloween parades

Gun advocates challenge zoos' bans on possession around US

Brown Visits UCC as Students Return to Class

Pipe break shuts off water in Yreka

Former congressman says DFS is "cauldron of daily betting"

Central Point Parks System Master Plan

Guns allowed at Oregon public schools?

USC fires Steve Sarkisian 1 day after putting coach on leave

Naturopathic clinic goes "rogue on healthcare"

Students return to Oregon community college after shooting

California may allow inmate firefighters with violent pasts

California governor bans Redskins name at public schools

Fred Meyer employee's hand stuck in pipe for hours

Running couple says 'I do' at mile 8 of Chicago Marathon

Quinn Cooper Memorial Attracts Crowd

UCC Set to Re-Open

Fishing Fundraiser for Treven

New program allows Medford residents to register cameras

6th Annual SoPride Parade

Uniting Against Hate

Strong emotions as Obama visits grieving Oregon town

Mt. Ashland gears up for upcoming season

The show must go on for Ashland hotels

Hanley Farm ready for Halloween

Emergency water shutdown in Yreka

Gun Shops Are Booming

Coastal Thefts On The Rise

Salty Water's Back In Harbor

Will Brookings Vote For An Additional Tax?

Anti-violence programs shut down as Chicago shootings climb

New California law extends privacy rights to electronic data

1 fatally shot at Texas Southern University housing complex

Obama focusing on condolences, not gun laws, in Oregon visit

Forest Service proposes timber sale in Elkhorn Mountains

Humorous wine bottle label strikes familiar chord with teachers

Oregon pot stores sell more than $11 million in first 5 days

1 dead, 3 wounded in shooting at Northern Arizona University

SOU honors Umpqua Community College

SOU praised for online proactiveness

Beyond 'Like:' 5 ways you might soon emote on Facebook

Music Coop Celebrates 40th Anniversary

Water Flush Discoloration

Woman describes issues at mine during trial of ex-coal CEO

Battery fires: FAA to back ban on passenger plane shipments

University of Oregon to offer free football tickets to Umpqua Community College students, staff

McCarthy abruptly withdraws candidacy for House speaker

Donald Trump says Bowe Bergdahl should have been executed

People pack meeting of panel eyeing expansion of whale tanks

Airlines post better on-time rate but get more complaints

License suspended for nurse accused of reusing syringes

Court: Hot yoga's sequence of poses can't be copyrighted

In Oregon visit, Obama will find grief but also resentment

Men suspected in armed car jacking in custody

Three Years in the Making: Oregon's Newest Sobering Center

Estate files lawsuit in death of woman in Murphy bed

US airman who helped thwart French train attack is stabbed

JCSO: Driver sought in Highway 62 pursuit

Man arrested on suspicion of sexually abusing minors

South Carolina still on edge from floods; 2 die in truck

Feds say first humpback whales of season spotted in Hawaii

Obama signs law preventing premium hikes under health law

Authorities track GPS to find 3 people sought in killing

Middle school receives Fuel Your School donation

New Body Cameras for Grants Pass Police

OSP arrest driver in August rollover crash that killed one

Pump Break in Grants Pass

Gun Classes In High Demand

American Red Cross and Sinclair: Home Fire Preparedness Campaign

SOU students say they feel safe

SOU to reopen Thursday

Coast Guard abandons search for 33 missing crew members

California governor signs aggressive climate change bill

Hawthorne Park to open Saturday

ODFW stocks fish for fundraiser for family of UCC victim

Planned Pacific Power Outage near Ashland Thursday

Oregon gunman killed himself after police shot him

Obama apologizes to aid group for US attack on Afghan clinic

"Notifeye" helps family stay in touch during emergencies

Unconfirmed threat closes SOU's Ashland campus classes

Bomb threat emergency plan successful

California governor signs law targeting gender wage gap

ACLU lawsuit: County jails people who can't pay court fines

Harvard's prestigious debate team loses to NY inmates

Ore. teen sentenced to 10 years in great-grandmother's death

Stolen truck found but tofu and organic drinks missing

Ex-UN General Assembly head among 6 held in bribery scheme

Disaster plan developed in case fire reaches nuclear waste

LAPD: Rap group posted video of gun flashed near officer

Texas executes inmate for killing man in $8 robbery

Thousands of federal drug inmates set for early release

Josephine County Fire Departments Suffer From Sheriff Budget Cuts

UCC Scams & How To Donate Securely

Police: Grants Pass teen arrested, intended to confront an officer

SOU to host UCC support events Thursday

Officials: Man arrested for sexually abusing teen

Oregon community colleges to hold vigils for Umpqua Community College

Oregon State Police arrest 2 for deer poaching

Oregon wildlife officials ask public to report sick elk

Pilot who became ill aboard flight died of natural causes

Ohio man calls cops to complain he got too high on marijuana

Mixed reactions to new California racial profiling law

Woman found inside portable toilet gets arrested on warrants

Students and Faculty Reflect on Re-Opening

Umpqua Community College Re-Opens

Marijuana dispensary hits business record with recreational sales

TPP trade agreement could put Oregon beef industry on map

Publisher apologizes for textbook calling slaves 'workers'

Hunter escapes attack by shoving arm down bear's throat

'Fire hose' of moisture slams South Carolina; 12 killed

Data hack at 7 Trump hotels confirmed

'Oh, my God': Man who finds missing 2-year-old girl jubilant

Marijuana pesticide flap brings consumer lawsuit in Colorado

Woman accused of injecting 14-year-old daughter with heroin

Supreme Court rejects San Jose appeal over Athletics' move

Amtrak train hits rocks on track, derails in central Vermont

Farmer opens barn to show woolly mammoth bones

Medford Library to re-open Tuesday following RCC bomb threat

Obama to visit Oregon shooting victims' families

Gunman ranted about not having girlfriend

No explosives found on Rogue Community College campuses, investigation ongoing

California governor signs hard-won right-to-die legislation

Motorcyclist dies following failed traffic stop

Woman arrested in connection to Wednesday Eagle Point pursuit

Classes Cancelled for Rogue Community College and SOU's Medford campus

All Rogue Community College campuses evacuated for bomb threat

Oregon shooter showed little sympathy in calculated killings

Pastor Shares Daughter's Story of Survival

Art Along the Rogue wraps up

Drive Less Connect program kicks off

Car wash held for UCC victims

Bubble Indoor Soccer bounces into Medford

Spiritual Candlelight Vigil

UCC Shooting Timeline

UCC Shooting Victim's Family Speaks Out

Medford Police Deals with Stolen Bikes Regularly

Drumming Up a New Audience at Music Festival

Community Members get Tour of Renewable-Energy Sites

Medford Fire-Rescue Debuts Sprinkler Trailer

Medford Battalion Chief Leaves for Roseburg

15 Now at the Talent Harvest Festival

How To Help UCC Victims

Bush, Clinton display the political divide over gun control

Accident on Interstate 5 overpass causes backup

Victims in UCC shooting identified

Oregon gunman was Army dropout who studied mass shooters

Sheriff maintains support for gun rights after mass shooting

Aunt of wounded victim: Nephew tried to stop college shooter

'We began to run': Students describe horror of shooting

No confirmed threat for Coos County

Potential threats against Ashland High School cancel homecoming parade

S.O.U. Response to U.C.C. Shooting

A Drive for Food Drives in Ashland

Gunman opens fire at Oregon college

Parkinson's Patient Walking Again

Medford Hospitals Stood By For Shooting Victims

Medford Police & Fire Station Update

Douglas Sheriff gives new UCC shooting numbers

Five acre fire reported near White City

Oregon leaders react to Roseburg shooting

Rogue Credit Union establishes donation fund for UCC shooting victims

Josephine County Sheriff's Office responds to Umpqua Community College shooting

10 confirmed dead in Umpqua Community College shooting

Bakery owners refuse to pay damages in gay wedding cake case

Ex-police volunteer who stole guns sentenced to prison

Your Sports: 09.30.2015

Take it or "Leaf" it: Ashland's Tree of the Year Nominations

Making Way for Recreational Marijuana

Ashland Co-op Outgrowing its Space

Marijuana dangerous for children?

Artist shot, killed while painting anti-violence mural

Amid Taliban gains, US military favors longer presence

Protestors hope governor will take action against pipeline

EPA sets limit for toxic pollutants released into waterways

Oklahoma sheriff indicted, plans to resign

Hurricane Joaquin gains force near Bahamas, heads toward US

Immigrants say about-face on visas costs them millions

Oregon regulators fine aerial pesticide spraying company

Hunters warned of fire danger

Compass House Celebrates First Birthday

Mt. Ashland announces fall pass sale

A Medford Apartment Complex Is Not Up To Code

MADGE: One in custody in Eagle Point pursuit, still searching for another

Josephine County Board of Commissioners sues Kairos Northwest, Umqua Bank

Patrolling for Weed

Only woman on Georgia's death row executed; 1st in 70 years

Eagle Point horse tests positive for West Nile virus

Jackson County Fire District 3 receives Lowe's Hero Grant

Coos Bay man fatally struck while trying to get mail

Things to know about recreational marijuana sales

One Man Resentenced Because Of A Supposed Computer Glitch

County denies land-use permit for Mountain View Paving

Authorities ask family of missing persons for DNA, records

Consumer agency hears about student loan servicing problems

Burned as baby, woman finally meets nurse who cared for her

Novelist quits teaching at Arizona college over loyalty oath

Keystone XL developer drops landowner lawsuits in Nebraska

Haunted Houses Take Safety Precautions

Environmental groups seek end to all Arctic Ocean drilling

Four vehicle crash on Highway 199 causes delays

Amazon tests Uber-like service for deliveries

Police: Mom tossed newborn out 7th-story window in New York

Trump breaks Fox News 'boycott' after 1 week

Catherine Coulson, who played Log Lady in 'Twin Peaks,' dies

How to turn off 'Wi-Fi Assist': the iOS9 update that could cost you thousands of dollars

Fugitive accused of kidnapping arrested after 24 years

Oklahoma panel orders removal of Ten Commandments monument

Facebook status hoax returns

Cooler weather changes game for motorcycle safety

Klamath County District Attorney's Office overwhelming amount of homicides

Brady Adams Tribute

Actor Paul Walker's daughter sues Porsche over fatal crash

Autopsy: High school quarterback died from internal bleeding

Drivers from Taiwan get reprieve from driver's license test

Idaho woman gets 1½ year term for California egg donor fraud

Washington state suspends operations of duck tour company

Takata air bag recalls could expand to 7 more companies

Senate advances stopgap spending bill to avoid shutdown

Planned Parenthood president 'proud' of fetal tissue work

Whole Foods to cut about 1,500 jobs over next 8 weeks

EPA rules will strengthen pesticide safety on farms

Oregon medical marijuana dispensaries gear up for rec sales

Marijuana bundle falls from sky, slams into family's carport

Cooking fire in double-wide kills two dogs

Strong evidence Mars has streams of salt water in summertime

Amphibious tour vehicle lacked axle fix before Seattle crash

Woman arrested in connection to weekend Klamath Falls murder

Exit 24 Opens Early

Crash on Highway 99

Students Love "S.O.U. Loves Ashland" Event

Growers and Crafters Market Concerns

Hot Air Balloon Fair Does More For Montague

Rally For Water

Labor Justice advocates speak against toxins

[an error occurred while processing this directive]

Newsmax Headlines

Sponsored content

Business News

Economists still expect rate hike before end of 2015

NEW YORK (AP) -- A survey of business economists says a majority still expect the Federal Reserve to raise interest rates before the end of the year, with the broader economy expected to grow at a slightly faster pace in 2015 than previously forecast.

Entertainment News


BOSTON (AP) -- It's not the kind of command performance he's come to expect as a comedian.

Get This


BILOXI, Miss. (AP) -- Dan Crossley has the "Best Cruiser on the Beach."

Science/Tech News


NEW YORK (AP) -- Civil liberties advocates are calling it an important advance -- one they hope will be expanded to the rest of the country.

  • KTVL :: News - Connect to Congress

    Connect to Congress

  • KTVL :: News - City In Crisis

    City In Crisis

  • KTVL :: News - Drive Safe Mode

    Drive Safe Mode

    Help keep you and your loved ones safe on the road, Pledge against distracted driving and support safety on our roads.
  • KTVL :: News - News10 Special Report

    News10 Special Report

    News10 investigates the issues affecting your town.
  • KTVL :: News - Across The Nation

    Across The Nation

    News and information from across the nation.
  • KTVL :: News - Border Crisis

    Border Crisis

  • KTVL :: News - Your Voice. Your Future.

    Your Voice. Your Future.

    As the country faces challenges from federal budget issues to jobs and national debt, your voice is critical to the future.
  • KTVL :: News - Health Care Reform

    Health Care Reform

     The Supreme Court ruling to uphold the Affordable Care Act sparked a new battle. Check here daily for the latest developments, locally and across the country.
  • KTVL :: News - Washington Times

    Washington Times

    Politics, Breaking News, US and World News.
  • KTVL :: News - Reality Check

    Reality Check

    How are your tax dollars being spent? Reality Check tracks whether local, state and federal governments or any groups are using your money wisely...or wasting it.
  • KTVL :: News - Your View

    Your View

    When you see news, share it with us. Your View is the perfect place to share the video and photos you capture your town.
  • KTVL :: News - Closings & Delays

    Closings & Delays

    Check here for closures and delays.
  • KTVL :: News - To Your Health

    To Your Health

    Dr. Dan, Monday KTVL News10 at 5 answers your health questions and discusses the latest developments in medecine. If you have questions, find the e-mail address and mailing address at ktvl.com.
  • KTVL :: News - Crime Stoppers

    Crime Stoppers

    Crime Stoppers, Medford, Southern Oregon's answer to crime at ktvl.com. Find a police report of the active case, descriptons of suspects, vehicle information, rewards.

  • KTVL :: News - Links from Our Broadcast

    Links from Our Broadcast

    Links and numbers from our newscasts at KTVL News10, Medford, Southern Oregon's news source. Relevant links to research topics of interest or to contact organizations.

  • KTVL :: News - Safety Links

    Safety Links

    Safety - links and numbers at ktvl.com. Emergency preparedness plans for Curry, Jackson, and Josephine counties' citizens. Links to California and Oregon Emergency Management Offices, National Safety Council, ...
  • KTVL :: News - Voting Links

    Voting Links

    Links to websites full of information and background material, as well as sites that help you take action.
  • KTVL :: News - Local Links

    Local Links

    Local links for Medford, Southern Oregon and Northern California. Community links for Curry, Josephine, Jackson, Klamath, Lake and Siskiyou Counties, schools, cities, chambers of commerce, Rogue Valley ...

more »

Tonight on KTVL

12:00pm:  News10 at Noon
12:30pm:  The Bold and the Beautiful
  1:00pm:  The Talk
  2:00pm:  Let's Make A Deal
  3:00pm:  Rachael Ray
  4:00pm:  Ellen
  5:00pm:  News10 at 5pm
  5:30pm:  CBS Evening News with Scott Pelley
  6:00pm:  News10 at 6pm
  6:35pm:  Who Wants to be a Millionaire
  7:05pm:  Family Feud
  7:30pm:  Celebrity Name Game
  8:00pm:  2 Broke Girls
  8:30pm:  Mike & Molly
  9:00pm:  Scorpion
10:00pm:  NCIS: Los Angeles
11:00pm:  News10 at 11pm
11:35pm:  The Late Show, with David Letterman
12:37am:  The Late Late Show

Complete Schedule »